HISTORICAL WALKING TOURS | BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS
  • Freedom Trail Tour
    • The Boston Massacre Tour
    • Boston Civil War Tour
    • The Kennedy Tour
    • The Boston Massacre Lesson Plan
    • Paul Revere's Row to Charlestown 4/18/1775
    • Virtual Tour of the Massachusetts State House
    • The Boston Massacre per the Pennsylvania Gazette
    • Paul Revere Lesson Plan
  • Revere Bells Index
    • The Stickney Revere Bell Listings of 1976
    • Paul Revere Bell of Beverly
    • Revere Bells in Boston >
      • Paul Revere Bell Old South Meeting House
    • California's 2 Paul Revere Bells
    • Paul Revere & Son's Bell Westborough Massachusetts
    • Falmouth, Massachusetts
    • Revere Bell Fredericksburg VA
    • Revere Bell Hampton NH
    • First Parish Church of Kennebunk
    • Revere Bells in Maine
    • Revere Bell in Mansfield
    • Revere Bell of Michigan
    • Revere Salem Mass Bell
    • Roxbury First Unitariarn Universalist Church and their Revere Bell
    • Revere & Son Bell, Savannah Georgia
    • Singapore Revere Bell
    • Tuscaloosa Bell >
      • History of the St John and Leavens Patriarchs
      • Samuel St John Jr Estate Genealogy
      • Authenticating the Revere Tuscaloosa Bell
      • Joshua B Leavens Last Will and Testament
      • 20th Century Tuscaloosa bell
    • Revere Bells Lost in Time
    • Revere Bells Washington DC
    • Revere Bell in Wakefield, Mass
    • Revere Bells Woodstock VT
  • Bostonians
    • Edward F Alexander of The Harvard 20th Civil War Regiment
    • Polly Baker
    • John Wilkes Booth
    • The Mad Hatter, Thomas, Boston Corbett who Killed John Wilkes Booth
    • Richard-Henry-Dana-Jr
    • James Franklin
    • Benjamin Harris of Publick Occurrences
    • Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.
    • William Lloyd Garrison
    • USS Thomas Hudner DDG116
    • Edward Hutchinson Robbins Revere
    • Amos Lincoln
    • King Philip
    • Mayor's of Boston
    • Mum Bett & Theodore Sedgwick
    • James Otis
    • Paul Joseph Revere
    • John Rowe >
      • John Rowe's Diary Entries
      • John Rowe's Dinner Party
      • John Rowe and the Jail Fire
      • Hang John Rowe?????
      • John Rowe the Fisherman
      • Joh Rowe's Tea Ship
    • Be Proud to be Called a Lucy Stoner
    • Rachel Wall , Pirate
    • Paul Revere the Coroner of Boston
    • Deborah Sampson
    • Who was Mrs. Silence Dogood?
    • Dr. Joseph Warren's Dedication
  • History Blog
  • Lilja's of Natick
    • Lilja Brothers Military History
    • Lilja's Family Album
    • Memorials and Tributes to the Five Lilja Brothers
    • Lilja Family Tree
    • Lilja Historical Family Tree Documents
    • Lilja References
  • Collage of Boston
    • 4th of July Parade, Bristol RI
    • Boston Harbor
    • The Customs House
    • Forest Hills Cemetery
    • Georges Island
    • Nonviolent Monument to Peace - Sherborn
    • The Battle Road
    • Skate bike and scooter park
    • Cassin Young & USS Cassin Young
    • MIT
    • Historic Charles River
    • The Roxbury Standpipe on Fort Hill
    • John & Abigail Adams National Park

We were Englishmen at heart but Antagonist in Law

11/17/2016

0 Comments

 

In theory the Puritans and Pilgrims left England in pursuit of freedom. On religious grounds the Pilgrims were being asked to leave but the Puritans had concluded that the English Church was straying from the scriptures so they took the initiative.  Yet, Parliament gave each group a business contract.  The land is yours, settle it, grow things, send some back to England at the end of every harvest. Mine things, fish things, build ships, but sell them back to England.[i]

 Each charter gave the immigrating company a territory and a license to regulate laws as long as it did not contradict the laws of England. The Colonial laws for murder, manslaughter, indenture, impressment, jury trial by your peers, habeas corpus et al, matured through the middle of the 18th Century and followed English common law practices.  After all, most Colonial lawyers and judges were initially trained by lawyers from England.  Each could have served well in the others court.

England was the most civilized nation in the Western Hemisphere, thanks to their “Glorious Revolution” of 1688 and subsequent Bill of Rights of 1689.  From herein Parliament became the only authority in England to make laws. The King had been promoted out of the process.   However, laws since the English Constitution seemed to work best for those in power, with land or wealth. One individual, both a Tory politician, professor, judge and jurist responded to the duplicity.  As a result of the merger of written and unwritten laws, Sir William Blackstone wrote four volumes to help the common man navigate through the English legal system.  The four volumes covered the rights of a person, of things, of private and public wrongs.  Today they are referred to as Blackstone’s Commentaries but were published as the “Commentaries on the Laws of England”.  The last volume was published posthumously in 1783. 

During Blackstone’s lifetime there were six million Englishmen[ii] and two million Colonists,[iii] yet more copies of his Commentaries were purchased in the Colonies than England.  Short of the Puritan Bible, Blackstone’s Commentaries were necessary reading for the common citizen to survive especially since the Colonies, Scotland and Ireland believed they were subjugated to second class citizenship. Along with a lack of representation in Parliament this unwritten second class status further divided the Colonies from its Parent.

Parliament outsmarted itself.  The legitimate establishment of Colonial legislatures instead of representation at Parliament, opened the door to a natural and pragmatic interpretation of English law. While the practice of setting precedents in common law were the same here and there, the pragmatic decisions soon caused conflict.  For instance, money was scarce in the Colonies.  If a judgement was rendered against you there were “New World” standards or choices to satisfy the verdict.  You could pay the fine, go to jail or become indentured to the plaintiff for three years or until you decided that options one or two were a better course. The three-year option was imposed by common law since many Colonist, particularly the young indentured, intransigent seamen and the poor had no hard currency.  Then consider the conflict that did arise as the law was applied to the British military in Boston.  If you joined a local militia generally you committed for a period of time limited by your family’s ability to support themselves or the need to harvest. The British planned a military campaign that endured until they won or lost.  If you left early  were you a deserter? You can correctly guess the divergent views of the Colonist and British military.  The requirement of the Colonies to purchase taxed English goods lead to smuggling on a wide scale.  Would you have considered John Hancock a smuggler?  His ship the Liberty was confiscated by British customs agents based on their interpretation of customs duties.  John lost a great ship and 900 bottles of Madeira wine.  By the way, the Liberty was converted to a British Naval frigate in 1768 and in July 1769, the Liberty confiscated two Newport Rhode Island commercial vessels.  The locals boarded the Liberty, off loaded the British seamen, then sailed it to Goat Island and scuttled and burned her.  That should clue you in to the inevitable conflict to come, both legal and military as judged by Englishmen of the same blood.

Early in the 18th Century numerous confrontations between the British military, Parliament and the Thirteen Colonies came about while each were interpreting law based on the same principles.  Our blog on “The Rose”, “These Colonist were a match for Parliament” and “Private Riley’s Debt”, will provide additional examples.

Our next blog will discuss the disdain that developed between the British military, the Colonial militias and citizens.  Perhaps that ancient proverb described it best, “the enemy of my enemy is my friend”.  In this case, Barely!   
 

[i] A paraphrase of many entries from many historical interpretations both English and American now and then.
       
                                                                Bibliography
Roots of conflict : British armed forces and colonial Americans, 1677-1763 / Douglas Edward Leach.

[ii] http://www.thepotteries.org/dates/census.htm http://www.tacitus.nu/historical-atlas/population/british.htm

[iii] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thirteen_Colonies  slaves not counted.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Abolitionist
    Adams
    American Revolutionary War
    AnteBellum Period
    Boston Civil War
    Boston Massacre
    Colonial Boston
    Colonial Law
    Korean War
    Politics In General
    Reveres
    Rowe
    The Secret Six And John Brown
    Travel To Boston
    World War I
    World War II

    Archives

    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016

    RSS Feed


​



    TO BE ON OUR MAILING LIST FOR NEW BLOGS

Submit

 Tours can be modified to be ADA compliant

mailto:walkbostonhistory@gmail.com


An association of tour guidES for educators, amateur historians, and the general public looking to walk beyond the Freedom Trail, concentrating on the legal, philosophical, emotional and political events of Boston.

-Follow us on facebook 
-Member, Massachusetts historical Society, 
-VOLUNTEER PHOTOGRAPHERS FOR fINDAGRAVE..COM
-Volunteer transcriber for the National Archives
-fOLLOW US ON TWITTER @WALKBOSTONHISt
​

  • Freedom Trail Tour
    • The Boston Massacre Tour
    • Boston Civil War Tour
    • The Kennedy Tour
    • The Boston Massacre Lesson Plan
    • Paul Revere's Row to Charlestown 4/18/1775
    • Virtual Tour of the Massachusetts State House
    • The Boston Massacre per the Pennsylvania Gazette
    • Paul Revere Lesson Plan
  • Revere Bells Index
    • The Stickney Revere Bell Listings of 1976
    • Paul Revere Bell of Beverly
    • Revere Bells in Boston >
      • Paul Revere Bell Old South Meeting House
    • California's 2 Paul Revere Bells
    • Paul Revere & Son's Bell Westborough Massachusetts
    • Falmouth, Massachusetts
    • Revere Bell Fredericksburg VA
    • Revere Bell Hampton NH
    • First Parish Church of Kennebunk
    • Revere Bells in Maine
    • Revere Bell in Mansfield
    • Revere Bell of Michigan
    • Revere Salem Mass Bell
    • Roxbury First Unitariarn Universalist Church and their Revere Bell
    • Revere & Son Bell, Savannah Georgia
    • Singapore Revere Bell
    • Tuscaloosa Bell >
      • History of the St John and Leavens Patriarchs
      • Samuel St John Jr Estate Genealogy
      • Authenticating the Revere Tuscaloosa Bell
      • Joshua B Leavens Last Will and Testament
      • 20th Century Tuscaloosa bell
    • Revere Bells Lost in Time
    • Revere Bells Washington DC
    • Revere Bell in Wakefield, Mass
    • Revere Bells Woodstock VT
  • Bostonians
    • Edward F Alexander of The Harvard 20th Civil War Regiment
    • Polly Baker
    • John Wilkes Booth
    • The Mad Hatter, Thomas, Boston Corbett who Killed John Wilkes Booth
    • Richard-Henry-Dana-Jr
    • James Franklin
    • Benjamin Harris of Publick Occurrences
    • Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.
    • William Lloyd Garrison
    • USS Thomas Hudner DDG116
    • Edward Hutchinson Robbins Revere
    • Amos Lincoln
    • King Philip
    • Mayor's of Boston
    • Mum Bett & Theodore Sedgwick
    • James Otis
    • Paul Joseph Revere
    • John Rowe >
      • John Rowe's Diary Entries
      • John Rowe's Dinner Party
      • John Rowe and the Jail Fire
      • Hang John Rowe?????
      • John Rowe the Fisherman
      • Joh Rowe's Tea Ship
    • Be Proud to be Called a Lucy Stoner
    • Rachel Wall , Pirate
    • Paul Revere the Coroner of Boston
    • Deborah Sampson
    • Who was Mrs. Silence Dogood?
    • Dr. Joseph Warren's Dedication
  • History Blog
  • Lilja's of Natick
    • Lilja Brothers Military History
    • Lilja's Family Album
    • Memorials and Tributes to the Five Lilja Brothers
    • Lilja Family Tree
    • Lilja Historical Family Tree Documents
    • Lilja References
  • Collage of Boston
    • 4th of July Parade, Bristol RI
    • Boston Harbor
    • The Customs House
    • Forest Hills Cemetery
    • Georges Island
    • Nonviolent Monument to Peace - Sherborn
    • The Battle Road
    • Skate bike and scooter park
    • Cassin Young & USS Cassin Young
    • MIT
    • Historic Charles River
    • The Roxbury Standpipe on Fort Hill
    • John & Abigail Adams National Park